For my first post, I wish to share with you an unedited piece I wrote for "RA diversity retraining." Although I planned on my blog having a bit of humor, this is a more serious piece relating to individual search for identity.
Am I Jewish?
I was too young to remember but when I was one year old and my father took me to my first baseball game, a man came up to him asked, "Are you Jewish?" My dad, being Jewish, responded that he was, but this curious stranger was not finished. "Is your son Jewish?" I don't know how my father responded, nor do I particularly care to, but regardless, I am still faced with the same question today.
I've never been to temple, and I've been to church on every Christmas Eve, but I certainly wouldn't characterize myself as Christian. I believe in neither God, in the Christian sense, nor Jesus being his son. But my disbelief in God excludes me from being religioiusly jewish as well.
It is clear then, that my Jewish identity is something cultural. So what does that make me? A cheap, bagel-loving, money-making individual? Well, I do like bagels and I am cheap, but does that really define me? I would rather define myself as a humanitarian, as a liberal, and as an intellectual.
Recently, however, I feel unable to separate myself from being Jewish. I somehow feel guilty about "my people's" actions against the Palestinians in Gaza. Why should I feel guilty? What do my Jewisheness and theirs have in common? Only the fact that we have been "the others" for so long that we must band together. Israel's actions in Gaza have made me reconsider whether I must continue to identify as Jewish and reevlauate whether or not I am Jewish.
Quote for the day:
"The unexamined life is not worth living" - Socrates in The Apology
identity is fluid. why must you have an identity?
ReplyDeletevery thought provoking. because you were "the others" for so long, does that necessarily mean you should band together? you are asking great questions
ReplyDeleteyah i have that same jewish cultural thing with none of the religiousness...
ReplyDeletebeing a part of "the others" mentality is a form of groupism. it is important to maintain the true identity of the group if one wishes to follow it, but can lead to imposing the identity on those not wishing for it. it can be seen in the 7% of those who do not believe in a god claiming that they are offended by holiday (specifically christian) decorations and signs and claiming their right to the removal of such signs. groupism is not always a somewhat ridiculous thing (as it is with 7% trying to impose on 93%) but rather can be viewed as a necessity at times. the 'us vs them' attitude is needed to form the unity required to achieve and to propell the group to new heights.
ReplyDelete...though this is seen with minorities, some try to claim it is seen in gender discrimination too, however it cannot be applied here. women are not a minority, yet are considered "the others". they do not view themselves as a group, for the most part, yet for negative terms/stereotypes they are classified as such.
ReplyDeleteanyway enough for my semi pointless rant. good luck finding yourself... we're all trying to do the same thing :-/